The 94 Killer is the main and major antagonist of the series, also the originator of the Lakewood Slasher. They were first mentioned in Pilot identified as Brandon James. The first physical appearance is presumably in Halloween.
- This killer has managed to keep themselves a secret for 20 years. There identity is rumored to be revealed during Season Three.
- Brandon James was accused of being the murderer due to his mask being the main face of the spree.
- Piper Shaw and Kieran Wilcox brought back the legacy of 1994, in 2015, the first murder of the present day was Nina Patterson and Tyler O'Neill.