The 94 Killer is the main and major antagonist of the series, also the originator of the Lakewood Slasher. They were first mentioned in Pilot identified as Brandon James.
- This killer has managed to keep themselves a secret for 20 years.
- Brandon James was accused of being the murderer due to his mask being the main face of the spree.
- Piper Shaw and Kieran Wilcox brought back the legacy of 1994, in 2015, the first murders of the present day was Nina Patterson and Tyler O'Neill.
- Maggie Duval has often stated that Brandon James could not be the 94 killer, as he was too nice to hurt anybody.